We’re awash with anecdotal evidence that outdoor swimming helps promote good mental health. Rowan Clarke explores the feel-good factor around taking a dip in cold water
It’s easy to count the physical benefits of swimming. But arriving at outdoor venues to improve fitness, train for events, or enjoy non-weight bearing exercise, outdoor swimmers have discovered something more – incredible benefits for mental health.
As word spreads about these benefits, more and more people take to the water during the colder months to improve their wellbeing. And while the anecdotal evidence is compelling, science is really only just starting to unpick the physiological reasons why a chilly dip is so curative.
Standing on the edge of a tidal pool in North Somerset with a group of people of all ages, sexes, sizes, shapes, backgrounds and abilities, the sense of camaraderie is palpable. Led by psychologist and life coach Claire Paul, this group has gathered at Clevedon Marine Lake every Tuesday morning for a year. Unlike many swimming groups, its focus is wellbeing rather than swimming technique.
Claire was inspired by a 2016 BBC documentary that followed a young woman with depression who replaced her drugs routine with cold-water swims as her main form of treatment. “This was what inspired me to start the informal social open water swim, coupled with my love of outdoor swimming and working with people who have depression and all that goes with it,” says Claire.
From a social point of view, the group’s camaraderie is exactly the kind of therapy doctors recommend for conditions like depression and anxiety. This, coupled with exercise and being outdoors, is self-care that has been prescribed for many years.
“I hoped to motivate people, provide them with the moral support to continue open water swimming all year and experience its amazing benefits,” says Claire. “I also hoped that it may provide a confidence boost and help anyone who wanted to overcome depression and anxiety.”
Exercise makes us happy. When you increase your heart rate by exercising, your brain recognises it as stress. Your body responds by releasing a protein called Brain-Derived Neurotrophic Factor (BDNF), which helps protect and repair your memory neurons. At the same time, you release endorphins which block the discomfort of exercise and make you feel euphoric.
Exercising outdoors is even more effective. In 2015, researchers studied the effect of exercise with simulated views of natural environments. A group of post-menopausal women were asked to do 15 minutes on an exercise bike while facing either a blank wall (control) or watching project videos of urban (grey), countryside (green) or coast (blue) environments. The test showed the most positive psychological results in the women who exercised in front of the blue video.
Bring together those three elements, camaraderie, exercise and blue views, and you start to understand why swimming outdoors has such a profound effect on our sense of wellbeing. But more recent research is starting to expand theories there are also physiological benefits from the cold water itself.
Clevedon swimmer, Pete White, has been swimming throughout winter for a number of years. “I have always been a very sociable person and have been keen to take part in group sports,” he says. “Whilst social interaction and walking, running, cycling, climbing etc. supported moderate relief from depression and anxiety, nothing has provided the benefits that cold water has.”
Cold water adaptation
In September 2018, the British Medical Journal published a case report about the theories around cold water adaptation as a treatment for depression. Co-authored by Dr Mark Harper, a cold-water swimmer who was behind the BBC documentary, the report looks at the physical responses to swimming in cold water.
The theory is around our stress response and inflammation. Immersing yourself in cold water puts your body into fight or flight mode. Starting with the cold-water shock response, dipping into cold water puts your body under stress. As you repeat this experience, you diminish this stress response. And having a better rein on your stress response means being able to better cope with life’s many minor irritations that add up to chronic stress.
“Our bodies don’t differentiate between types of stress,” says Mark. “Every day low-level stresses make things worse, but the significant physical stress of getting into cold water attenuates our stress response as we adapt to it.”
This diminished stress response is about activating the parasympathetic nervous system. Known as the ‘rest and digest’ system, the parasympathetic nervous system is responsible for slowing your heart rate and increasing intestinal and gland activity.
A key part of this system is the vagus nerve, which connects your brain to organs including your heart and lungs. It’s the tone of this vagus nerve that relates to mental health; if you have high vagal tone, your parasympathetic nervous system is working and that means that your body can relax faster after stress. One way in which you can stimulate the vagus nerve and increase vagal tone is through cold water adaption. And this has been shown to help a range of mental health and nervous conditions from depression and anxiety to chronic fatigue, tinnitus and Alzheimer’s.
We also have an inflammatory response to threat, including stress and infections. “Inflammation and depression are linked,” says Mark. “Anti-inflammatory drugs like ibuprofen have an effect on depression. But all drugs have side-effects. And we know that cold water adaptation reduces levels of inflammation.”
While some therapists suggest cold showers or immersing your face in cold water, it’s becoming clear that these techniques aren’t a patch on outdoor swimming. “Cold water swimming is a holistic therapy,” says Mark. “Exercise, being in nature, community – the cold water is an additional effect.”
Looking forward to winter
“I had been diagnosed with depression and anxiety at the age of 17,” says Pete, who is looking forward swimming through another winter. “I took a cocktail of medication to be functional and mixed social activity and physical activity where I could. However, cold water swimming really does appear to kick off a physiological reaction that in turn must affect chemical, hormones in the body and brain that led to me being able to be drug free at the age of 33. I’m currently dead excited about the temperature dropping – nuts, hey?”
As temperatures drop, Mark and his team will be looking for people who have used cold water swimming to help treat any condition or symptoms to help with next stage of his study. While water at 20 degrees Celsius certainly gives us many wonderful benefits, the plummeting temperatures have a much stronger effect.
Thinking about trying cold water swimming? Follow open water coach Rowan’s tips:
Join a local group for safety and that all-important camaraderie. Start now and dip at least once a week to stay acclimatised
Get in quickly – it takes 90-120 seconds for the initial cold-water shock to wear off
Never jump in – hyperventilating underwater is bad!
Gently exhale as you enter the water
Listen to your body and don’t stay in for too long
Bring layers, a warm drink and a hat for afterwards